Legal experts criticize Delhi police the wire editors search and seizure CB News

CB News

The case of action against The Wire is strange. Might say that even The Wire’s report on meta was weird. But the media organization admitted its mistake, also apologized and then withdrew those stories. The Wire also filed a case against Devesh Kumar, the researcher who prepared the report and allegedly tampered with the evidence. Then the question is, when the media institute has accepted its mistake, then why did the police raid all of a sudden? Why were devices like mobiles, iPads, laptops of The Wire editors confiscated? Have the rules been followed for this? The question is also that why were the equipment of the accused who helped in preparing the report and tampered with the evidence were not confiscated?

The confiscated devices like mobiles, iPads, laptops of the editors of The Wire do not threaten to reveal the identities of their sources? Will the investigative journalism of news websites and their reports not be affected? This question is because The Wire is part of the consortium that published investigation reports into cases like Pegasus. Pegasus is a military-grade snooping software allegedly used by the government to spy on opponents.

latest news

In fact, these questions are being raised by experts in legal matters and technical matters after the police action on The Wire. Know the whole matter before knowing what the experts are raising.

Amit Malviya on Friday submitted a complaint against The Wire, Varadarajan and the editors – Siddharth Bhatia, Venu and Janhvi Sen – to the Special Commissioner of Police (Crime). After this, on Saturday, those journalists were accused of fraud, forgery and publishing ‘fake reports’. Apart from this, charges like defamation, criminal conspiracy have also been leveled. The raid was also conducted on Monday.

This is after The Wire has taken down that report related to tech company Meta from its website. Many questions were raised on that report. The Wire filed a police complaint on 29 October against its researcher Devesh Kumar, alleging that he ‘fabricated and supplied documents, emails and other material such as videos to damage The Wire and its reputation. did’.

More news from the country

Malviya said The Wire published the follow-up reports, despite META’s categorical denial that the report had cited forged documents. Following this, the Delhi Police conducted searches on the homes, offices and equipment of The Wire’s founding editors and senior editors on October 31.

However, legal experts have said on this action that the Delhi Police hastened the action. This is highly unpredictable and is contrary to official action in other similar cases.

Online news website Scroll has reported based on legal experts. This confiscation action was taken under a notice sent under Section 91 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. This section allows the police to issue summons to any person to produce material necessary for investigation.

Further, it has been said that there is no link between investigation in fraud and defamation case and confiscation of equipment. As reported by Scroll, criminal lawyer Shahrukh Alam asked, “What are the investigators hoping to find, in a situation where the editor is admitting that the email was tampered with and has withdrawn its report based on that email.” ?’ “I think this is a very serious breach of privacy,” he said.

Alam said that since The Wire has admitted a mistake, the explanation already given by him can be examined. He said, ‘Without doing anything on the explanation, you bypass it for no apparent reason and reach out to see all the devices.’

The lawyers also questioned why the police did not seize the equipment of Devesh Kumar, whom The Wire alleges had tampered with the material on which these articles were based.

Lawyer Vrinda Grover asked why Malviya did not name Devesh Kumar in his complaint while The Wire is “telling that he has been misled and deceived”. He asked, ‘How did the crime branch not issue a notice to Kumar?’

The lawyers also criticized the confiscation of equipment as per the notice of Section 91. The notice under this section has to state what documents and equipment are required.

Grover said it is even more important in the case of journalists. “Since their tools are supposed to collect a lot of sensitive data and material relating to a large number of reports, state agencies are interested in accessing such material,” he said.

Grover said The Wire was part of a consortium that published an investigation into Pegasus. The impact of media persons doing such investigative journalism having access to sensitive information can be disastrous.

In addition, the police should have given the ‘hash value’ of the devices to their owners after seizing computers, iPads and phones. Hash value is a unique number used to ensure that a device and its data are not tampered with. “If the electronic devices are confiscated by the police without giving the hash value, then the electronic data and devices in the possession of the police can be tampered with and manipulated,” Grover said.

Related news

“It is very interesting that Delhi Police comes with a large number of policemen, but not with a technical expert to calculate and give the hash value,” he said.

Legal experts say that in other cases, the police rarely act so swiftly. Senior advocate Sanjay Ghosh, as reported by Scroll, said, “It is clear that the police do not act with such promptness in dealing with complaints made against people who have security and strength.”

He raised the question that Delhi Police had not conducted such investigation in cases like Nupur Sharma, who was associated with BJP. Sharma had allegedly made religiously inflammatory remarks in May. “When it comes to people like Mohammad Zubair or Varadarajan, the promptness with which the police act only gives the impression that there is discrimination,” Ghosh said. In May, Zubair, the co-founder of fact-checking website Alt News, was asked to hand over his electronic devices. His was used to make a tweet allegedly hurting religious sentiments.

,.

RELATED ARTICLES

Former Union Minister cum JDU’s former national president RCP Singh arrived...

CB News *RPC Singh started the public relations yatra by offering prayers...

Those who got the shops, they filled the form only to...

CB News Understand the black marketing of plots for shops like thisThe fair area is limited. In this too, out of...

Infection cases in the world exceed 63.24 crore, death toll crosses...

CB News Share: According to the updated data of the Union Health Ministry till 8 am on Sunday, the death toll has increased to 5,30,500...

IND vs ZIM: India won the toss, decided to bat, eyes...

CB News IND vs ZIM: In the match against Zimbabwe, India won the toss and decided to bat first. The Indian team has...

Khalistani terrorist organization will give ₹ 10 lakh to the accused...

CB News Khalistani separatist organization Sikh for Justice (SFJ) has announced a grant of Rs 10 lakh to Sandeep Singh, accused of killing Hindu...

BJP failed in Mokama, celebratory atmosphere at Anant Singh’s house CB...

CB News Desk Report: In Mokama, once again the flame of Anant Singh is going to be shattered. Anant...

Pakistan Supporters Of Former Prime Minister Imran Khan Ransacked Stone Pelting...

CB News symbolic picture - Photo : ANI hear the news hear the news The fear of civil war is increasing as the protests in...

Odisha: 650 Maoists Supporters Surrendered In Front Of Police News In...

CB News symbolic picture - Photo : ANI hear the news hear the news In Odisha, there has been a big success in the hands...

Ind Vs Zim T20 World Cup Live Streaming Telecast Channel: Where...

CB News India captain Rohit Sharma and Zimbabwe captain Craig Irwin - Photo : Social Media hear the news hear the news The fifth match...

Five people injured, ambulance driver seriously injured. Five people injured,...

CB News Anuppur25 minutes agoKotwali police station area Omni ambulance and storm vehicle collided. 5 people have been injured in this accident. ...

Most Popular

How did Salman Khan get the name ‘Bhai Jaan’? CB News

CB News Salman Khan recently explained in one of his interviews how he got the name Bhaijaan. Photo archiveBollywood actor Salman Khan is...

Some constituencies are fighting for the caretaker government, Fawad Chaudhry CB...

CB News Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) leader Fawad Chaudhry says that some constituencies in Islamabad are fighting for the caretaker government, it is being worked...

The movie “Legend of Mulajt” did a record business of 90...

CB News The movie "Legend of Mulajt" did a record business of 90 million in Pakistani cinemas, Amara Hikmat. Lahore (Imran Raj) - Renowned producer...

Those who fled abroad will no longer be able to leave ...

CB News Karachi: FIA has decided to get modern technology to prevent wanted accused from escaping abroad. In this regard, sources say that FIA...

Sara Inam Murder Case, Accused Shahnawaz Ameer and Accused Mother –...

CB News The Islamabad local court has indicted the main accused Shahnawaz Amir and his mother Samina Shah in the murder case of Pakistan-born...

Russia agrees to supply oil and diesel to Pakistan at reduced...

CB News The Minister of State for Petroleum, Dr. Mossadegh Malik, has said that agreements have been signed between Pakistan and Russia for...

In the first Test, England defeated Pakistan CB News

CB News Rawalpindi: England beat Pakistan by 74 runs in the first Test match. On the fifth and final day of the first test match...

The Israeli president met with Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed Al Nahyan ...

CB News Israeli President Isaac Herzog arrived in the United Arab Emirates after completing his visit to Bahrain.He was received by the Minister of...

Afghan Taliban claim foreign involvement in Pakistan embassy attack CB News

CB News External Afghan Taliban Involvement in Pakistan Embassy Attack... Kabul (Web Desk) The Taliban government claimed the involvement...

Goblin Mood 2022 has been declared as the word of public...

CB News 93 percent of people voted for Goblin Mode/Stock PhotoA year ago, the experts at Oxford Dictionaries threw up their hands and declared...

Rapidly rising interest rates are a cause of economic woes: experts ...

CB News KARACHI: Experts say that the State Bank of Pakistan has sharply increased the interest rate, which may make the economic situation...

Russia will supply petrol and diesel to Pakistan at a reduced...

CB News Islamabad: Minister of State for Petroleum Mossadegh Malik says Russia will supply crude oil to Pakistan at a reduced price. ...

Lalu Prasad’s Kidney Transplant; The daughter donated a kidney CB...

CB News Singapore City:Renowned Indian politician and former Bihar Chief Minister Lalu Prasad Yadav, 74, underwent a kidney transplant operation in Singapore. According to Indian...

The Election Commission’s decision to remove Imran Khan from the party...

CB News Islamabad: The Election Commission has initiated proceedings to remove Imran Khan from PTI chairmanship due to disqualification in Tosha Khana reference....

Had attention been paid to building dams, the country would have...

CB News Islamabad: Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has said that if attention had been paid to the construction of dams, the country would have...

RECRUITMENT OF CSIR SCIENTISTS 2022: MONTHLY SALARY UP TO 123100 CHECK...

CB News CSIR recruitment 2022: Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) is recruiting qualified candidates for the posts of Scientist, Senior Scientist and...